The Independent London Newspaper
25th March 2017

Blanket 20MPH speed limit idea for whole of Camden branded "wishful thinking"

    Published: 17 October 2012

    By ALICE HUTTON

    A MANDATORY 20mph speed limit for all vehicles could soon be rolled out across the borough of Camden. 

    The Town Hall wants to restrict all roads in order to reduce the number of accidents and get residents walking and biking. 
     
    It comes a week after a consultation survey on whether to curb the speed of cars in Primrose Hill came to an end. The move follows neighbouring Islington’s decision a year ago to force all road users to observe a 20mph limit – becoming the first area in the country to do so.
     
    The New Journal’s sister title, the Islington Tribune, later revealed that police believed it to be “unenforceable” and that they would not prosecute drivers who violated it. 
     
    A public consultation will be held if the plans are agreed in December and a spokesman for the council said a meeting with the police would be scheduled to discuss how to avoid a similar situation. 
     
    Cabinet councillor Phil Jones said that not only would it “prevent road casualties” it would “give greater confidence to the pedestrians and cyclists who use our roads”.
     
    He added: “A borough-wide rule would also ensure a more consistent environment for drivers who would no longer have to move confusingly between borough roads with different speed limits. We believe that drivers want to play their part in making the streets safer and making Camden a better place to live, work and visit.”
     
    Tony Armstrong, chief executive of charity Living Streets, called the proposals “enlightened” and said that the council should be “applauded”.
     
    But Keith Peat, the regional co-ordinating manager for campaigning non-profit group, the Association of British Drivers, said the move was “counter productive”.
     
    The former police driver added: “In congested areas, 20mph zones often have drivers more focused on the speedometer so they don’t get a fine than, say, keeping an eye out if a child runs across their path.”
     
    In their 20mph proposals, the council claim that statistics from Transport for London show a 6 per cent decrease in accidents for every 1mph reduction, including a more than 20 per cent fall in accidents in Belsize Park, which has been under a 20mph zone since 2006. 
     
    But Conservative councillor Jonny Bucknell, who sits on the London Transport Liaison Committee, said that trying to slow vehicles down won’t stop accidents.
     
    “Cities are 30mph places for 30mph people,” he said. “The idea that everyone will enter a 20mph zone and suddenly turn into Postman Pat is wishful thinking. The idea of 20mph came from research some time ago that a person is more likely to survive a collision at 20mph than 30mph. There are so many variables in a collision that the speed is only part of the equation.”
     
    * Camden Council have removed a proposal from their 20mph Primrose Hill consultation after an “error” caused residents to comment on a zebra crossing in an incorrect location. Cllr Jones said: “I’d like to apologise on behalf of the council for this error and any confusion that has arisen. We will consult local people separately at a later date on the proposal for a zebra crossing to reduce the amount of confusion caused by the original error.”
     

    Comments

    Beware, 20mph is dangerous!

    I live in Islington and last week the council brought in a mandatory 20mph limit for the whole borough.
    I try my best to observe the speed limit, but cars CONSTANTLY flash me, drive right up my bumper beep their horns and finally overtake me me causing a much greater hazard to pedestrians!! It's extremely unnerving..
    I also rIde a moped and it is now extremely dangerous for me. Mostly for the reasons listed above (even more dangerous for a biker!) but also due to the fact that a motorbike or scooter is NOT STABLE at 20mph!! stability is achieved at speeds higher than 25mph, at 20 you just wobble about!
    this law is dangerous!!!

    This is a joke!

    What sort of comment is "Cities are 30mph places for 30mph people"!? That is the most ridiculous comment I have ever heard, as is the claim that people will just be looking at their speedometer all the time if they drive at 20mph. It cant be that hard to, once you are at 20mph, to stay more or less at 20mph!

    Regarding enforcement, just put a camera or two up here and there - that seems to be what is happening everywhere anyway so why no do so for a 20mph zone?

    “Cities are 30mph places for

    “Cities are 30mph places for 30mph people"? Conservative run Lancashire doesn't think so, nor Bristol, Portsmouth, Chichester, Oxford, Cambridge, and a growing number of other communities. Even basic GCSE Physics shows that speed is the major part of the equation both in the ability of road users to avoid accidents, and the severity of damage and injury should a collision occur.

    Lies, damn lies, and statistics

    "a 6 per cent decrease in accidents for every 1mph reduction"

    On that basis if they cut the limit from 30 mph to 10 mph there would be less than zero accidents?

    Post new comment

    By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.